Monday’s Mtg: Who Won the Democratic Presidential Debate?

By the time we meet Monday it will have been six days since the first Democratic presidential debate. The instant Media analyses of who won and lost will be old news, new polling will show who got a bump from their debate performance and who didn’t. And, I imagine we’ll be back to obsessing over the fringe candidates leading the Republican field again. Maybe Ben Carson will have declared that Christian martyrs in the Coliseum would have beaten the lions if only they had been packing heat, or something [oops – guess not.] What will be left for us to ponder?

Well, substance, for one thing. Despite moderator Anderson Cooper’s best efforts, the five Democratic candidates – Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders, Martin O’Malley, Lincoln Chafee, and Jim Webb – talked a lot about substantive issues facing the country. These included gun control, banking regulation, criminal justice reform, and foreign policy. They also debated each other’s political philosophy, especially during Hillary and Bernie’s colloquy on the meaning of socialism and progressivism. It’s still very early and no one votes until late January, 2016. Still, I think we got some clues on how Hillary, assuming she wins the nomination, will run a general campaign against a zealous GOP determined to stop her from succeeding Obama.

Below are links to watch the debate, some instant analyses of it, and a few deeper think pieces on the 2016 election. I’ll see you all Monday 7pm.

Discussion Questions –

  1. SO WHAT? Do presidential debates ever matter? Could they matter more this election than most, because of Trump or some other factor?
  2. GOALS: What was each of the 5 candidates trying to accomplish in the debate? Which constituencies were they trying to impress?
  3. SUBSTANCE: What policy issues did they discuss and what did they agree and disagree on? What did we learn that’s new or important?
  4. SUBSTANCE? Were any really important topics ignored or fudged by the candidates? Why? Are Benghazi and the emails dead issues?
  5. STYLE: Who failed to impress?
  6. WHO WON: What constitutes “winning” a debate and who decides? How does the Media define it? How do you think people watching decided?
  7. BROADER ISSUES: What is Hillary’s basic strategy to become president? What is Sanders’s strategy?


This debate –

The Commentary –

What they ignored:

The Bigger Picture –

Next Week:  The Transgendered in America.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: