Monday’s Mtg: Does the Constitution Need Updating?

The $64,000 question in American politics in the last decade has been, what went wrong?  Why is our political system so gridlocked and unable to address the nation’s problems?  Everybody has their favorite explanation and we’ve talked about a lot of them.  Polarization and voter sorting.  Money in politics.  An extreme and/or dysfunctional Republican Party.  Too many Americans dependent on government spending.  Too much government interference in the economy.  Barack Obama.  People that agree with Bruce.  Or with me.

In case you didn’t know, some experts pin a lot of the blame on the Constitution itself.  They point out that no other nation on earth is governed by a founding document written over 200 years ago and amended barely at all in the last 100 years.  They draw a straight line between the Constitution’s alleged flaws and archaic provisions and many of our longstanding political problems, especially the gridlock.  A lot fo these experts have their own wish list of amendments they say would update the constitution for the 21st century.

None of them are going to be adopted, of course.  It’s almost impossible to amend the Constitution at all, given the need for a 2/3 vote in both House and Senate and ratification by ¾ of the states.  Worse, any amendment that would substantially alter our political system also would upset the current distribution of power within it. I suggested this topic anyway because I think it is illuminating to consider how constitutional restrictions affect our political problems and whether and how a different set of rules might change things.  I also think that where people stand on prominent proposed constitutional amendment reveals a lot about their political values and priorities in our democracy.  Progressives and conservatives have very different ideas on what’s wrong with our Constitution and/or what’s wrong with the way we interpret it.  I’ll explain more what I mean in Monday’s opening.

Lots of links this week.  I tried to highlight the pithiest and best ones.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS –

  1. Why did the founding fathers make the Constitution so hard to amend?  Was this wise or an error?
  2. Can today’s political problems really be laid at the Constitution’s feet, or do they have other origins?  Which are the most problematic parts of the Constitution and why?
  3. What major amendments have been proposed to “update” the constitution?  Do you think any of them would improve the functioning of the system?
  4. What do our opinions about this subject reveal about our political philosophy and political motives?
  5. Workarounds:
    1. Are there ways to “get around” the constitution’s restrictions or archaic parts other than by amendment?
    2. What about calling a constitutional convention of the states?  Would this bypass Washington and the special interests – or be taken over by them and/or by ideological partisans?

LINKS – The Problem (or is it?)-

Solutions –

Next Week:  Why Do Grass Roots Political Movements Succeed or Fail??

Advertisements

One response

  1. The recent proposal in the Senate to overturn Citizens United by amendment got a majority, strictly on partisan lines–every Republican voted no!
    But of course, a majority is not enough.
    As David says, it’s practically impossible to amend.
    While other countries have changed constitutions the way we change our clothes, the veneration for our ancient document seems unshakable. More important, the present dominance of the Republocrat party–the two-party monopoly–is almost impossible to break.
    Of course, one might argue that consitutional machinery isn’t really the problem; the deep division in the country is perhaps more fundamental.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: