Monday’s Mtg: Do Americans Agree On What Freedom Means?

It annoys a lot of American liberals that the word, “freedom” has achieved a kind of totemic status on the political right.  Witness last week’s annual Conservative Political Action Committee (CPAC) conference, or any Tea Party-oriented gathering.  Only conservatives know what liberty is.  Anybody that disagrees doesn’t understand freedom or is trying to destroy our freedom.  Etc.  Really grating.

But, it would be very inaccurate to say the Tea Party is the first American political movement to insist it alone understands the true meaning of freedom.  A few years ago I read an interesting book called, The Story of American Freedom.  The historian author believes that defining “freedom” has been the central animating struggle of U.S. history.  That history, he says, is a more complex story than most of us assume.  It has not been a simple, linear march towards greater and greater liberty, or even a story of a fixed set of freedoms being extended to new groups of Americans.  Rather, he says, each American era sees its consensus on freedom’s meaning challenged.  It gets defended, and a revised definition – usually more expansive, but not always –  evolves.  How can this be in a country that’s core values are supposed to be fixed in the Constitution and even universal?

Good topic idea, I thought, especially since the way our history works, if the Tea Party wins, their version of freedom becomes the right one.  On Monday, I’ll just open up by listing some kinds of freedoms (like economic, religious, etc.) and tracing his basic argument of how freedom’s meaning has evolved.  This will be short and with little detail since you all don’t need a history lecture.  Then, in discussion we can apply it to our times and our political wars.

Discussion Questions –

  1. What are the different “types” of freedom: Political freedom, economic, religious, speech, privacy, family autonomy, etc.?  How are they related?
  2. How has the definition of freedom changed throughout American history?  How has the concept evolved in the last 4o years, as our politics has polarized along liberal/conservative lines?
  3. Liberal Freedom:  What do you think is the current liberal definition of freedom?  Your critique?
  4. Conservative freedom:  Same.
  5. How do you think most regular Americans define freedom?  Do they agree on its main components?  How different is that from the definitions liberals and conservatives seem to have and wave around all of the time?

Links –

NEXT WEEK:   Do/Should International Organizations Have Power Over the U.S.?


2 responses

  1. What you characterize as a “fire-breathing, liberal view” seems to me to be right on.
    It’s amazing to me how our friends on the right consistently neglect economics. How can one be free without a dollar in one’s pocket?
    They would surely know that, if they’d ever had the experience (which they haven’t); or could even imagine it.
    Yes, the people sleeping out on the sidewalks here in San Diego are as free as the air. Of course…

  2. I think it was the French philosopher Montaigne that said the law in its majesty allows rich and poor alike to sleep under a bridge and steal food to eat. I am not at all familiar with his work, but I remember the quote.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: