Monday’s Mtg: Is There a Growing Dependence On Government?

I thought we’d try something a little different for a few weeks.  Our next 4-5 meetings take on directly some of the major political themes that today’s conservatives sound.  For me, there could be no other choice for the first topic than the “growing dependency” on government idea.

In case you didn’t know, the idea that Democrats in general – and Obama in particular – want to get Americans “hooked” on government is a major, major theme on the Right these days.  One hears it over and over and over again on talk radio, conservative websites, and other media outlets.  Dependency on government programs, they say, is rising, and the public only voted for Obama twice because he first promised and then delivered freebies to his voters.  This meme has a powerful appeal to millions of Americans and seems to have become a core belief among conservatives.  Poor people are no longer lazy, it seems; they’re seduced into dependency on the State.  They are victims of liberalism.

It is easy – way too easy, speaking of seductive notions – just to dismiss it all as covert racism and willful blindness to seeing the worst recession since WWII and the fracturing of the job market for low-income Americans.  One of my big goals for Civilized Conversation is to try to understand things most of us want to dismiss out of hand and to examine them on their merits.  Could there be anything to this idea of growing dependency on government?  What if the economy stays flat for years?  Regardless of the merits of this notion, why is it so appealing to conservatives?

I’ll open our meeting by introducing the topic and summarizing the evidence for growing government dependency. Then, we can perhaps debate in a civilized fashion why so many of our countrymen believe in this.

Discussion Questions –

  1. What do they mean by a growing dependence on government?  What evidence do they cite and how do they (or do they!) rebut the obvious counterarguments?
  2. Who really benefits from government?  Do we really redistribute much?  If so, why?
  3. Why does the dependency meme resonate so strongly with conservatives?
  4. Could there actually be a problem here?  What if private sector jobs don’t come back?  Will dependency advocates be right?

Links –

The argument

Rebuttals/Evidence –

NEXT WEEK:    Do Americans agree on what freedom means?


2 responses

  1. The idea of dependency bears some examination and definition.
    Bishop Romney, for example, lives off the dividends and profits of his various investments, the security of which, in the last analysis, depends on government.
    Does that mean he is dependent on government too?
    Most wage earners are “dependent” on a company for their basic living expenses.
    What if the company fails?
    David, I think you are very generous in conceding so much merit to the views of “conservatives” (a real misnomer, by the way).
    I see it quite differently. Most of their so-called “ideas” are simply cover for their self-interest. They want to keep as much of their money as possible, and pay as few taxes, even to the detriment of their own long-term interests!

  2. If you are interested in knowing more about the characteristics of who actually receives food stamps, you can access a report here: It shows that nearly a third of food stamp households have earnings (meaning that someone in the family works) and only about 7 percent receive cash welfare benefits.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: