Monday’s Mtg: North Korea – How Will This (and It) End?

Just a quick intro post this week, since the issues surrounding North Korea are pretty obvious. Since the fall of communism, the nations that have to deal with North Korea have all had the same basic strategy: Try to keep them from doing anything too crazy and destabilizing while waiting patiently for the whole regime to collapse. Now they have nuclear weapons (maybe 6-8 warheads, without looking it up) and they are testing longer-range missiles. They also have a new leader, who’s 27; maybe totally in charge, maybe not; and making bombastic threats that are extreme even by North Korea’s standards.

What does this mean? Anything different? What do we do now? Anything different? We can focus on this crisis. But, I thought it might be helpful to might discuss the future we know is coming sooner or later: Regime collapse and the many, many dangers that follow.

We’ve talked before about failed states, the Arab Spring, how wars end, etc.  Some authoritarian states fall relatively peacefully (South Korea, Eastern Europe), or at least without severely damaging our interests (USSR, Argentina, Burma just recently). Others fall ugly or really ugly (Congo, Syria).  Why the differences, and which will North Korea be, and when?  What can we do to prepare for the inevitable?

Discussion Questions

  1. What is the latest crisis all about?  What is the evidence that North Korea is becoming more of a threat than it always has been?
  2. What does the West know about what is motivating the new aggression?  Is it an indicator if strength, or weakness?
  3. Regardless, should we be more worried about the regime’s intent or its capabilities?
  4. Should the United States be doing anything different with regard to North Korea?  What do we need other countries to do and how can we get them to do it?
  5. The future:
    1. When will the regime start to totter?  What are the signs to look for?  What can we learn about signs from our failure to predict the USSR’s fall and so many others’ collapse?
    2. Do we want it to fall?  Do China and South Korea want it to fall?
    3. How dangerous will the fall of North Korea be?
    4. What can we do now to plan for making the situation less perilous?

Links –


3 responses

  1. James H. Zimmerman | Reply

    Understanding Chinese policy is probably the key to the N. Korea situation, as they, the Chinese, undoubtedly hold the fate of the regime in their hands.
    However, as in other areas, Chinese policy is not too clear.
    I hope we will discuss this.

    1. Yeah, I should have linked to an article on China’s motivations/intentions. I’m sure they feature in the other articles I listed.

  2. The danger evaporated, as expected. People love being the top dog, especially those who experience being absolute dictators. Once there, almost everyone does whatever they can to stay in power. Jim Jong Un is no exception. From what I have seen he loves controlling everyone. That is why these guys love nukes. It is not so they can attack others, it is to keep from being attacked. One nuke makes it just about impossible to invade the country without massive retaliatory damage. So the regime is that much more stable.

    Judging from the recent replacement of the top general, it does not look like there is much chance of an internal revolution either. So my guess is that the status quo will continue for the foreseeable future.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: