Monday’s Mtg: Reforming Campaign Finance After Citizens United

The Citizens United ruling of January 2010 seems to have woken up a lot of people to the new, cold reality about big money’s dominance of our political system and the inherently political role the Court plays in our democracy.  Still, exactly how far-reaching the impact of the ruling will turn out to be is a little unclear.  Speculation abounds, some of it based on misconceptions about what the ruling said and what was already legal before.  Correcting some of those misperceptions can make the situation seem both less and more dire.

So, it’s a nice topic for our first meeting at a new place and on a new night.  Speaking of that, I may have spread some confusion earlier.  Coco’s is not going to insist that everyone who attends each meeting spend $10 per night.  Rather, they just expect a decent-sized check to come out of that room that’s in some proportion to the number of people being served.  I’m afraid meeting for free in a public place every single week is just a tall order and I could not find places that will allow it without some expectation of making a few bucks.  So, just do the best you can.  Pie and coffee can be had there for about $7, plus tip.

I’ll open the meeting by explaining (1) the legal basis for the Court’s ruling in Citizens, and (2) what the decision changed in campaign finance law and what it did not change.  Then we can discuss whether this decision is really as transformative as people say it is and how screwed we really are.  I’ll end my introduction by listing some of the ideas for fixing the system to put giant, unlimited, anonymous money at least partway back in the bottle.


  1. What did the Citizens United ruling say?  What law did it change?
  2. What was the basis for the Court‘s decision?  What constitutional and political values did the opinion express?
  3. Qui bono?  What has been the result so far?  How might this affect the 2012 election and future elections?
  4. Does unlimited and anonymous individual and corporate funding of campaigns really threaten the integrity of our elections and our democracy itself?  On what evidence?
  5. With five justices dead set to defend Citizens as settled law, what can be done to put the big money genie back in the bottle without going through the current Court?



See you all on Monday night!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: