This Week’s Mtg: Why Are People Hostile to Mormonism?

A Mormon will be the Republican nominee for President in 2012!  Seriously, that’s not on the order of a black president, but it’s surely a sign of American religious tolerance.  Still, the evidence is pretty clear [link added] that Romney’s religion is hurting him among evangelical Republican primary voters, and may hurt him in the general election, as evangelicals are not the only Americans suspicious of Mormonism.

A lot has been written on Romney’s personal history in the Mormon (LDS) Church.  But, we’ll be debating the election all year off and on, so I thought for one night we could discuss the religion itself: What is Mormonism and why is it so controversial?

Based on last week’s group discussion, some of you know a lot more about this religion than I do or that I could learn in a few days.  So, I’ll just open the meeting by summarizing a few facts about Mormons in the United States – numbers, stated beliefs (according to surveys), the who/what/when/where stuff.  Then in our discussion I hope we can debate both aspects that seem to me to be implicit in this topic: (1) What is Mormonism and what do Mormons believe? And (2) why are people so hostile to it?  I hope we can talk about the factors that might motivate people to hate Mormonism beyond just the sect’s odd theology; e.g., psychology, culture, etc..

NOTE:  This week I’m providing lots of background links.  They mainly cover basic Mormon beliefs and practices, but some offer defenses of some of their more unusual ones.  I’m going to read them all and I hope you will read a few, too.


  1. What are Mormons like on the United States?  How “different” are they from other Americans, in terms of lifestyle, education, income etc.?
  2. What do Mormons believe?  How monolithic are they in their beliefs?
  3. How different is Mormon theology and everyday beliefs of Mormons from other American Christians?
  4. Who cares?  That is, is Mormonism influential in our politics or culture outside Utah and a few other places?  What about for a President Romney?
  5. Why do so many people seem to dislike and/or distrust Mormons?  Is it the LDS’s history, with its polygamy and insularity?   It’s secretiveness?  Its theology and hierarchy?
  6. Are Americans really getting more tolerant of religious or ethnic/racial minorities?  Why/why not?



Mormons in the United States –

Mormon beliefs and practices –

Critiques and Defenses of Mormonism –

We haven’t done a religion one in a while.  Hope to see you all there at Eclipse Chocolat.


2 responses

  1. What people outside the Mormon Church may not realize is that LDS doctrine emphatically embraces the U.S. Constitution, as it sees the Constitution as divinely inspired. For any patriotic American, there probably won’t be much argument over that assertion.

    The issue here is that the LDS Church (the religion) has indoctrinated its members into the notion of a divine document (the state) that comes from their God for their blessing. A blessing which came from the Providential hand on the history of America, with the advent of the Constitution, for the sole purpose of bringing about the restoration of the gospel – through the prophet Joseph Smith – and establishing the true church in order to prepare the earth for the second coming of Jesus Christ.

    Thus, the LDS doctrine purposely combines church and state. Therefore, at the very least, the line of separation between church and state amongst devout Mormons tends to be blurred.

  2. James H. Zimmerman | Reply

    I am patriotic, but I don’t believe the Constitution is divinely inspired and I reject that belief.
    I don’t think it is very helpful to venerate the Constitution, or anything else, for that matter.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: